This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… HOISTED FROM THE ARCHIVES: Reading Practices for Tomorrow’s Infotech WorldOriginally 2023-07-28. Hoisted & separated out so I will easily be able to find it in the future. From <https://braddelong.substack.com/p/briefly-noted-for-2023-07-28-fr>…Originally 2023-07-28. Hoisted & separated out so I will easily be able to find it in the future. From <https://braddelong.substack.com/p/briefly-noted-for-2023-07-28-fr>…Books vs. ‘Bots: Will we still be able to take black marks off of a page into our eyes, and use them to spin-up a sub-Turing instantiation of the author’s mind to run on our wetware? Or: Machiavelli, Sokrates, & the attention-smashing internet. Reading is an ancient cognitive technology; the internet is disassembly. Who wins? Will we still be deep- and active-enough readers to conjure living interlocutors from dead text? Sokrates distrusted and scorned the written word; Machiavelli feasted on it nightly to satiation. In a world of generative everything, which habit survives? Reading Practices for Tomorrow’s Infotech World:Today’s food for thought:
And:
As I say: A good reader takes the black marks on the pages of a book, spins up a sub-Turing instantiation of the mind of the author from those black marks, runs that instantiation on a sandboxed partition in their own wetware, and then argues with that instantiation. The end result of this process? Niccolo Machiavelli puts it very well in his “Letter to Vettori”:
Machiavelli is, as people call it these days, an “active reader”: someone who when reading a book induces in themself a kind of multiple personality order that allows them to derive all—or nearly all—of the benefits of active dialogue with another mind from mere black marks on a page. In so doing, Machiavelli short-circuits Socrates’s objection, in Phædrus, to books. In Socrates’s story, the God Theuth [Thoth, ] shows King Thamus his invention of writing, and Thamus responds that it will:
And Socrates analogizes writing to:
Thus Socrates’s very strong preference for interactive oral dialogue over written text as a way of pursuing philosophy—living and dynamic form of discourse that could adapt to the needs and abilities of each interlocutor, and that could stimulate the soul to discover the truth. Socrates’s critique of writing was, of course, ironic, since we only know his thoughts and arguments through the books written by Plato. Plato accepted (or originated? Plato’s character “Socrates” has a fraught relationship to the real Socrates) by dialogues, myths, allegories, metaphors, and so on. It was only Aristotle who went all-in on books, trusting that they would find the right kind of, or enough of the right kind of readers. Bernoff is strongly on Machiavelli’s side, but in his Writing Without Bullshit and elsewhere he recognizes that most (all?) readers need a good deal of help to start the spin-up of the sub-Turing instantiation:
Motivated and curious readers can and do read like Machiavelli. But one problem is that people these days are reading less and especially reading less in the way of long form extended arguments. Thus detailed multi hour engagement via a book with another mind (or with the self-created illusion of another mind) is becoming much less common, and that will make us much less good at it. This is a problem for books. Minkel does not believe this is a problem. She argues that, historically, books have resisted disruption by technology because they offer this distinctive mode of engagement—this spin-up of a sub-Turing instantiation—that appeals to many. But in the modern world of the internet and ChatBots, will we lose our ability to so-easily submit to the power of words to create immersive and imaginative worlds that readers can explore at their own pace and in their own way? Quite possibly. Modern technologies may well destroy, via their parcelization of our attention and thus our building-up of our reading neuronal patterns, much of our collective ability to make the use of books that we have made of them for the past 2500 years. It will be interesting to see what happens. References:
If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…#hoisted-from-the-archives |
HOISTED FROM THE ARCHIVES: Reading Practices for Tomorrow’s Infotech World
Sunday, 26 October 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



No comments:
Post a Comment