This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… Yes: AI Is a Bubble. But It Is a Bubble-Plus. & That Makes a Substantial DifferenceBubble-double-plus: how the AI boom props up the economy with debt, data centers, faith, and valuations without rational expectations of durable and monetizable productivity growth…Bubble-double-plus: how the AI boom props up the economy with debt, data centers, faith, and valuations without rational expectations of durable and monetizable productivity growth…The number of people uneasy about the flywheel between the macroeconomy, the stock market, and the ongoing AI bubble is growing. Here is Tracy Alloway:
Yes: the AI-bubble is pushing up investment spending directly via construction of data centers, and indirectly via valuation effects on consumption. And then the multipliers kick in. If not for sky-high optimism about AI, the economy would now be in recession with high probability. This sky-high optimism has pushed stocks up to remarkably high valuation ratios rivaling those of the very end of the 1990s: And this in spite of long-term bond rates that are quite low in historical perspective—inconsistent with any sort of strong expected future productivity boom that might generate income to validate such high valuation ratios. Low bond rates even when there is a furious AI bubble-driven data-center capital investment boom—they are certainly registering the presence of a global savings glut, if not of full-blown secular stagnation: As best as I can see, this sky-high optimism about stocks is not warranted. And here is the very sharp Gillian Tett is right now sounding the alarm about the shift in AI data-center funding to debt and to circular vendor financing. When the people who are giving you the money do not trust that your speculative enterprise, that is a bad sign. And when you can only get customers by lending them the money to buy your products—that is a very bad sign too. Gillian Tett:
But, right now, it is a bad sign only for those invested in the technology’s long-term superprofitability and in making money by building and running data centers. For while it is to some degree a Ponzi scheme, it is not “just” a Ponzi scheme. And that makes a big difference: that means that it will probably go on for quite a while, and that when there is the ultimate shakeout the tech world will look very different and very weird because of all the money poured into data centers, software development, and business-model experimentation. Back up. These days I like to say that the AI bubble is eight things. It is:
Of these, only (1) and (3) are likely sources of superprofit for investors. (6), (7), and (8) are transformative, potentially, for human society and culture, but not likely sources of superprofits from investors in providing AI-services or AI-support right now. (5) is a defensive move: not an attempt to boost the profits of platform monopolists, but to spend a share of those profits—a large and growing share—defending them against Clayton Christensenian disruption. (2) and (4) are culturally important, and are driving much of investor interest on the belief that with so much excitement about this pile of manure there must be a pony in there somewhere. But focusing on them is not likely to lead to good investment decisions. Yes, the grifters moving over from crypto are definitely trying to run a Ponzi scheme: if the person trying to sell you something has just spent a decade selling BitCoin, DogeCoin, and Web3 use cases coming real soon now, you should probably block them and add them to your spam list. And anyone saying either of these two things: (i) soon everyone will be under threat from a malevolent digital god that will soon control all of our minds through flattery, misdirection, threats, and sexual seduction, the negative millennarians; or (ii) they are on the cusp of building a benevolent digital god. Shake your head and walk away. And if they then turn to “give me money! lots of money!”—well, then run... Keep reading with a 7-day free trialSubscribe to DeLong's Grasping Reality: Economy in the 2000s & Before to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives. A subscription gets you:
|
Yes: AI Is a Bubble. But It Is a Bubble-Plus. & That Makes a Substantial Difference
Thursday, 30 October 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)





No comments:
Post a Comment