This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… On the MCM6 Milk Consumption Switch & Lactase Persistence; & the Nonexistence of Any Such Switches in IQ Genetics "Race Science"This is too close to the “let’s get out the skull-measuring calipers” discourse. I shouldn’t have to do this. Any genetic variants that made us genuinely smarter at dealing with situations without...This is too close to the “let’s get out the skull-measuring calipers” discourse. I shouldn’t have to do this. Any genetic variants that made us genuinely smarter at dealing with situations without incurring a strong energy-use penalty would have rapidly made a “hard sweep” through the East African Plains Ape population long ago. We see this in cultures with domesticated potential-dairy animals. Strong selection pressures—2% to 5% per generation—has created large groups of humans who have DNA variants that flip switches so they can comfortably drink milk as adults; but there are no counterpart genetics-embedded switch-flips we have found that make people higher-IQ…We know exactly how adults keep digesting milk: enhancer tweaks at MCM6 turn up LCT. Decades of promises about IQ genetics have delivered correlations, not causes. IQ inheritance remains a statistical fog—limited heritability, many environmental and nurture cofounders, really tiny identifiable mechanisms. Hype, excuses, and vanishing variance explained. Let us start with milk: We understand the genetic basis of lactose persistence—LP, the ability of adults and not just the very young to digest the sugar lactose, and hence milk, comfortably—in the East Afrfican Plains Ape. The phenotype is typically defined by sustained intestinal lactase-phlorizin hydrolase (LPH; gene LCT) activity beyond weaning. Genetically, LP primarily associates with variants in the regulatory-enhancer DNA region upstream of LCT within the adjacent gene MCM6. Multiple, geographically structured alleles—including the canonical rs4988235 DNA single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) characteristic of northern and western Europeans, as well as distinct variants common in East African and Middle Eastern pastoralist populations—demonstrate convergent evolution during the Holocene. These variants exhibit some of the strongest signals of recent positive selection in the human genome, with estimated selection coefficients often between ~0.02 and ~0.10, depending on ecological context and modeling assumptions. Ancient DNA reveals a striking lag between the arrival of domesticated dairy-producing animals in human settlements and the spread of LP alleles, implying gene–culture coevolution with temporally variable fitness advantages, mediated by pathogen burden, seasonality, famine risk, and life-history trade-offs. At the level of molecular biology and regulatory architecture at the LCT/MCM6 locus, we understand LP thus: In the typical mammal, lactase-phlorizin hydrolase (LPH; gene LCT) is expressed in the brush-border membrane of small-intestinal enterocytes. In most mammals, LCT transcription decreases after weaning via developmental epigenetic programming (notably changes in histone marks and DNA methylation in LCT regulatory regions), resulting in lactose malabsorption. But LP is the maintenance of high LCT expression into adulthood. Note that genotype-to-phenotype mapping is high effect but context-dependent. The gastro-intestinal tract is a complicated system. Adults with the genes for LP can still get sick from drinking milk. Adults without the genes for LP can—sometimes, under some circumstances—tolerate drinking milk without getting sick. The LCT gene resides on chromosome 2q21, adjacent to MCM6. Adult expression of LCT to produce LP hinges on enhancers embedded within MCM6 introns. The canonical European variant is rs4988235. 13910 DNA bases upstream of the start of the LCT gene, what is normally cytosine base has been replaced by a thymine base. This enhances transcription factor binding to increase expression of the LCT gene in adults. Epigenetically, LP alleles correlate with reduced methylation in enhancer regions in adults, consistent with active chromatin states. Importantly, cis-regulatory control explains the large allele-specific effect sizes without coding changes in LCT. The underlying gene making LPH never changes. What changes is the degree to which MCM6 allows it to keep making proteins after weaning. In addition, in many Europeans, there is also rs182549: 22018 bases before the start of LCT, a guanine has been replaced by an adenine. This single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) is less functionally effective an enabling LP, but rs182549 and rs4988235 tend to occur together. In East African and Middle Eastern populations, there are other sources of LP. We have:
At the level of population-genetic signatures and evolutionary dynamics: This is convergent evolution in the East African Plains Ape: once you acquire domesticated animals that can potentially be used for dairy, your chances of survival as an adult if you can comfortably drink milk go up. The amount of going-up is substantial across the three hundred generations of human evolution since the beginnings of non-dog animal domestication. Hence at least some degree of LP has evolved and been selected for at least five different times in human populations. Estimates of the positive selection pressure for those with the European rs4988235 variant often fall within the range of an increase of between 2% to 5% of an individual’s chance of passing on his or her genes, both because milk provides calories and because milk is sometimes much safer when the water carries pathogens. The East African pastoralist variants show similarly strong or stronger signals, with rapid rises over the past 3–5 millennia consistent with cultural adoption of pastoralism. At the level of the archaeological and demographic context inferred from aDNA and ethnographic data on the spread of domesticated dairy-producing animals: It looks as though, in European populations, variant rs4988235 mutated and evolved and then swept through the population, hard and fast, millennia after domestication, for it looks as though there was a substantial time lag between the taming of potential dairy animals and LP: first technologies of fermentation and cheese-making were used to purge the lactose from the dairy food, and only later did rs4988235 sweep through populations late in the Bronze and early in the Iron Age. In Africa, the expansion of LP aligns with pastoralist expansion across the Great Rift Valley and into the Sahel. Even today, LP exhibits a very strong geographically and ancestrally derived pattern across the population of the East African Plains Ape:
But that was not the point of this post. The point of this post is that we understand the genetic influences on LP, but we do not understand the genetic influences on IQ. And yet Charles Murray claims that we do. Now comes to my feed Eric Turkheimer:
But Charles Murray disagrees:
From my perspective, Murray’s claim that this is not “something that lends itself to 1,500 words, or 3,000 for that matter, written for a lay audience” is pure bullshit. Lactose persistence—the ability of adults to drink milk without getting sick—in European and European-diaspora populations is overwhelmingly the result of the replacement of a cytosine base by a thymine base 13910 DNA bases upstream of the start of the LCT gene. As a result, the MCM6 gene does not flip the switch that turns off the LCT gene after weaning, and prevents it from producing the intestinal lactase-phlorizin hydrolase enzyme needed to comfortably digest lactose. That took 80 words. Suppose that IQ differences in the East Afericn Plains Ape population were to be strongly genetically determined by twenty different SNP mutations. With 80 words to describe each one and its effects, we are well under 3000 words. The Atlantic Monthly cannot publish the technical bioneurochemistry, but it can summarize what the technical bioneurochemistry means quite well. Before he settled on the “I really won, and I will explain, but not now” explanation, Murray had a different line. He agreed that he had lost his bet with Turkheimer, because:
To which Sasha Gusev has a full rebuttal:
“Question his world-model…”—now that is excessively polite. The basic genetic basis of lactase persistence can be told in semi-plain English: within European and European-diaspora populations, the SNP at −13910 C>T near LCT boosts adult lactase digestion via the LPH enzyme, with parallel variants across pastoralist ecologies. Ancient DNA shows a lag, then rapid sweeps; selection coefficients are quantifiable. Europe’s rs4988235 SNP DNA variant is a textbook “hard sweep;” East Africa’s LP variants are a “soft sweep “mosaic—both traceable, testable, and meaningful. These tiny enhancer edits built real fitness in tough environments where milk was calories and clean hydration. Meanwhile, the grand project to decode IQ at the genetic level stalled: big samples, tiny effects, higher heritability on paper than in DNA, and mechanisms missing in action. Common- and rare-variant studies explain a sliver of variance, collapse under sibling controls, and fail to deliver biological pathways. The contrast is the point. Gene–culture stories can be precise and cumulative when biology cooperates; with intelligence, precision has not arrived. That gap makes a mockery of premature certainty. If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…#on-the-mcm6-milk-consumption-switch-lactase-persistencePlease forward the email & otherwise share it to everyone you think would appreciate it… |
On the MCM6 Milk Consumption Switch & Lactase Persistence; & the Nonexistence of Any Such Switches in IQ Genetics …
Friday, 17 October 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



No comments:
Post a Comment