This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… Chaos-Monkey Trump, Tomahawk Missiles, & the Art of Sanewashing: On the Nearly-Irresistible Temptation to Normalize NonsenseTrump’s behavior is stochastic, not strategic. Smart people keep retrofitting “grand design” onto random flailing—and look foolish when reality shows up at the door an hour or so later. In the Holy...Trump’s behavior is stochastic, not strategic. Smart people keep retrofitting “grand design” onto random flailing—and look foolish when reality shows up at the door an hour or so later. In the Holy Name of the Storm God of the Semites, why do this?…That trick never works! Or, perhaps:
Witness:
Within hours after the posting of this interview, we had:
So, lo and behold, Putin’s position, it turns out, is not significantly weaker than it was at the beginning of the year. He may have been mad—probably was—at Putin two months ago in Alaska. But he is not mad now. There are signs that Niall did not really believe what I quote him saying above, but was simply expressing hopes about things that might be true—that Trump was about to releases Tomahawks to Ukraine:
He does not say “that’s the key… to what President Trump will do”. He says “that’s the key… to what President Trump has to do”. Not: this is the future that Trump—the most consequential leader of the West since Reagan—will create. Instead: this is what his advisers who want to avoid disaster on the Pontic Steppe need to chivy Trump—chaos-monkey that he is—to do, or else there will be disaster on the Pontic Steppe. And if Trump doesn’t—as he didn’t, and, it is overwhelmingly likely, won’t? Well, then, in Ferguson’s estimation, disaster is indeed likely. For, Ferguson goes on to immediately say: Putin is in fact winning the war. It is Ukraine’s relative position that is deteriorating. It is more likely than not that it is Ukraine that will look back next summer, and will then regretfully conclude it should have strained every nerve to settle the war right now. So why do smart, highly articulate people with a wide range of knowledge do this? Sanewash Trump, that is? Rather than say: “The right interpretive frame is this: chaos monkeys throw feces at random targets—it is what they do”? I cannot say that I know the answer. The thoughts of people who are still in the sanewashing-Trump business are opaque to me. I do, however, have my guesses: Consider how somebody used to using their words to be smart and analyze situations is likely to respond to something that is, at bottom, ungovernable and uninterpretable chaos. What are the pressures, in terms of their short-run incentives to say things that the system will be rewarded, their long-run vision of their identity as an intellectual doing worthwhile work, and the epistemic traps that their training and history lead them to fall into? I see three major threads:
As a historian, an analyst of the current geopolitical situation, and someone who hopes to have continuing and extended influence: Ferguson’s Cold War II lens forces him into a standard pattern, rationalizing chaos as shock tactics and bargaining with autocrats amid reduced US leverage, thus finding a way to narrate chaos as strategy. But there is more. Additional pressures on Ferguson and others driving them to do what they do that I see include:
Back early in Trump’s first term I thought the key to understanding Trump was to recognize that he was defined by his hatreds, like Andrew Jackson. Andrew Jackson, hated, more-or-less in order: Floride Calhoun (for her treatment of Peggy Eaton), John C. Calhoun (for being married to Floride Calhoun), John Quincy Adams (for elbowing him out of the presidency in 1824), Henry Clay (for enabling John Quincy Adams to rob him of what he had thought was his clear 1824 victory), bankers, the Cherokee, the Choctaw, the British, British-allied New England merchants and financiers. When analyzing Andrew Jackson, ask the question “which side of the question contains more of those he hates”, and then bet that he would take the other side. Quite reliable. But with Trump even his hatreds are not constant. If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…#chaos-monkey-trump-tomahawk-missiles-the-art-of-sanewashingPlease forward the email & otherwise share it to everyone you think would appreciate it… |
Chaos-Monkey Trump, Tomahawk Missiles, & the Art of Sanewashing: On the Nearly-Irresistible Temptation to Normaliz…
Saturday, 25 October 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)





No comments:
Post a Comment