This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… On the Deeply Corrupt Republican JusticesConstitutional Moments & Constitutional Mischief: The Court, Trump, the Limits of Law, Emergency dockets, partisan rulings, and the peril of a judiciary that never expects to have to answer to the...Constitutional Moments & Constitutional Mischief: The Court, Trump, the Limits of Law, Emergency dockets, partisan rulings, and the peril of a judiciary that never expects to have to answer to the current loyal opposition…In the era of Trump, the Supreme Court’s conservative bloc has wielded the emergency docket as a weapon, dispensing unexplained, often incoherent rulings that favor Republican interests and undermine legal norms. Lower courts—once the backbone of judicial process—find themselves chastised for not divining the true intent behind these shadow decisions. Thus the emergency docket has become a mechanism for partisan advantage as the Court’s Republican majority has repeatedly exempted Trump and his allies from established legal standards. Is this how “constitutional moments” have, in reality, always worked? The Age of Jackson, Reconstruction, Reconstruction’s Reversal into Jim Crow, the New Deal, the Civil Rights Revolution—all those political causes won repeated elections by convincing majorities before “the Supreme Court follow[ed] the election returns”, as Finley Peter Dunne wrote in 1901. (The context? The Insular Cases, in which the Supreme Court decided, contrary to all previous practice and precedent, that the Constitution did not automatically follow the flag into newly-organized U.S. Territories when not just a few Amerindians but a lot of brown people already lived there, as was the case with Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines.) But this seems to be a different kind of Ackermanian Constutional Moment—one engineered not from popular votes and mobilized public opinion below, but fro above. Indeed, the future and existence of American democracy hangs in the balance. Steve Vladeck appears to at least contemplate that the Republican justices might be people one can at least attempt to reason with:
Here is Hurley:
And Ian Millhiser sums it up:
Yale law professor Bruce Ackerman had a theory of “constitutional moments”. Ackerman argued that it was a legitimate part of American governance to change the structure and meaning of the Constitution without going through the formal amendment process outlined in Article V. Ackerman argued that, occasionally, American governance shifted into a period of heightened public debate and mobilization, during which a political party proposed major changes to doing things that did more than stretch but rather contradicted previous and prevailing constitutional interpretations. When the public then repeatedly endorsed those changes through elections, those new statutes and practices become embedded in constitutional law, even without a formal amendment. Ackerman’s examples were Reconstruction, its late-1800s reversal with the coming of Jim Crow, the New Deal, and the 1960s Civil Rights Revolution. The Supreme Court accepted changes in the way the law worked and what the law meant as constitutional, despite the lack of formal amendments. In Ackerman's view, these “constitutional moment” shadow amendments were as fully legitimate as formal amendments, as they required broad public participation and consensus-building, rather than just elite negotiation. I have long thought that the Age of Jackson should count as a constitutional moment as well. Andrew Jackson probably never actually said “John Marshall has made his decision, now let him enforce it”, but it is very clear, to me at least, that Chief Justice John Marshall had a Supreme Court majority behind him who thought (a) that stealing their land from the Cherokee was very bad juju, and (b) that when the black letter of the law required them to rule they would so rule to protect the Cherokee, but (c) they would use every procedural trick in the book to avoid having to actually rule to materially protect the Cherokee’s property—for a fight with Andrew Jackson was one that they would probably lose, to the long-run detriment of the court and the nation. The difference between then and now is that (a) John Roberts is on Trump’s side in a way that John Marshall was not on Jackson’s, and (b) Jackson was genuinely popular in the nation as a whole—his brand of populism as to what America was and would become regularly won elections up until Stephen A. Douglas decided to push the Kansas-Nebraska Act in 1854. The most scary thing to me is that this mode of behavior makes long-term sense for the six Professional Republican justices only under one condition. It makes sense only if the future that they contemplate is one of there never ever ever again being, simultaneously, a Democratic President, a Democratic Senate Majority Leader, and a Democratic Speaker of the House. For even the bluest of Blue Dog Democrats in the Congress, a Supreme Court focused on finding ways to make sure that laws passed by Congress do not bind a Republican President is unacceptable. And so breaking the constitutional principal that the Article I branch is the most powerful invites the complete neutralization of the future Supreme Court. If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…#on-the-deeply-corrupt-republican-justicesPlease forward the email & otherwise share it to everyone you think would appreciate it… |
On the Deeply Corrupt Republican Justices
Monday, 8 September 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



No comments:
Post a Comment