Lagging Edge will have a Permanent GlutThe direction is clear, the lagging edge with exposure to Chinese markets will have a glut.Hey, it’s been a bit of time. I have been swamped at SemiAnalysis. Remember, most of the best work happening in Semiconductors and AI is already underway at SemiAnalysis. We offer a diverse range of products, as well as numerous job opportunities available. We are currently hiring for various roles, including accounting, general operations, sales, and data engineering. Today’s post mixes free and paid content. First up: Texas Instruments. TI’s quarter was rough—optimism that the analog cycle had finally turned fizzled when management said it would cut inventory into the supposed “upturn.”
They’re now guiding to the low end of capex, signaling the COVID-era grand capex plan may never be needed. Texas Instruments also guided another disappointing quarter; extending the lagging-edge slow-motion train wreck. This is the tail of the long auto/industrial cycle: a huge upswing followed by a slow bleed. The glut has run roughly twice as long as a typical downturn, and even the “green shoots” were tariff-distorted. April’s pop was mostly pull-forward; that tariff-driven pull-forward was taken as fake demand.
And since then, it’s been slowly bleeding out in terms of the pull-ins. The run rate of demand is actually lower.
There is no upcycle in the lagging edge, and it continues to look like there’s a giant oversupply capacity globally. This is especially true for products that compete with China’s lower-end offerings, which Texas Instruments is clearly in the midst of. Remember, supply and demand dynamics are very fragile to incremental demand and supply, and I think the big X factor here is incremental Chinese demand. Even if there is an incremental 5% increase in supply during the upswing, that means the incumbents likely lose significant pricing power, and the value of their capacity is clearly impaired. And as we see lackluster capacity percentages globally, it’s becoming clear that the writing is on the wall. This inventory cycle for Automotive and Industrial is as bad as it has ever been, and the stocks are coming to realize that China has permanently inflated the lower end for the lagging edge. I wrote about the edge price war in 2023, and it’s pretty much been a one-way slog since then. Lagging-edge capacity is structurally different, and while we may experience another upturn, it should be much more muted and prolonged. There is something clearly broken in the automotive and industrial industries. Texas Instruments is right to move down inventory. They won’t be needing it as much anyways. Lagging Edge Perma GlutThe thing that I think no one really wants to admit is that lagging-edge capacity might be structurally different now. At one point in time (yes, in this newsletter), I discussed how even lagging-edge capacity might receive a bid as semiconductor demand skyrocketed. In this piece, I talked about how lagging-edge prices had to go up:
But the reality is that lagging edge took price in a temporary market upturn, and its now time to revert back to the mean. The old economic trend line is back in effect. There is not a meaningful new amount of demand for old chips, and if there is, it’s being made and consumed in China. The super cycle of COVID, with a new supply line from China that doesn’t care about capacity, leads me to believe we are much closer to the forever glut version. There is a long history of Chinese manufacturers flooding the lower end of the market. State-directed capital expenditure leads to higher output, often at the expense of economic efficiency. I wrote about this concept of Involution in my recent piece. I think it's time for products with 90nm and above to internalize the permanent China glut. The companies refuse to believe it, but I have the case studies of Solar modules, LCDs, LEDs, Steel, Shipbuilding, and Batteries. Companies can and will win share in this world. However, this will be achieved through performance and packaging, rather than by producing an older chip at a lower cost, which was the previous approach of the last generation. ADI is a master class in adding capabilities, or even MPWR, which has focused on higher-end power. However, the long tail is likely to face a flood of Chinese supply. Good luck to the older fabs! I cannot resist talking about Marvell behind the paywall. ... Continue reading this post for free in the Substack app |
Lagging Edge will have a Permanent Glut
Thursday, 4 September 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)




No comments:
Post a Comment