This is Brad DeLong's Grasping Reality—my attempt to make myself, and all of you out there in SubStackLand, smarter by writing where I have Value Above Replacement and shutting up where I do not… HOISTED FROM THE ARCHIVES: Origins of the Noah Smith-Brad DeLong-Dan Wang 2015 Pizza Dinner at Zachary'sDining, not philosophers, but economists. We tried to settle the following questions: Was the big risk in early 2009 that excessive monetary and fiscal stimulation would turn the U.S. into...Dining, not philosophers, but economists. We tried to settle the following questions: Was the big risk in early 2009 that excessive monetary and fiscal stimulation would turn the U.S. into “Argentina”, as John Cochrane had claimed? No. Why did John Cochrane claim that it was? I have no answer other than that over the decades he changed from being a smart young economist into a moron. Why didn’t he rethink any of his intellectual commitments after the world turned out not to correspond to his fantasies? God knows—but I do find that a lot of people do become professional ideologists whose opinions are not designed to describe the world but rather to please some group whose approval they crave…Gerard MacDonnell <https://bsky.app/profile/gmacdonell.bsky.social/post/3lxvlcs7r5k2o> wants this reference. So, since it is about to vanish from TypePad forever, here it is: Is the U.S. at Immediate Risk of Rapidly Becoming "Argentina" as a Result of Expansionary Counter-Cyclical Policies?: The Bet with Noah Smith: Noah Bravely Takes the Cochrane-Argentina SideThe bet:
The start was my noting that Sebastian Mallaby these days is sounding like a normal reality-based economist--and is far, far from the guy who back in March 2009 thought that what the audience at his CFR conference really needed to hear was the (unrebutted: the panel was stacked) opinions of John Cochrane:
Cochrane than protested (sounding to my ear much like an old-line Marxist who claims that Marx never said real wages will fall but only that there was a tendency for the real wage to fall) that he had not said that unless the expansionary fiscal and monetary policies of 2009 were reversed the U.S. was about to experience an Argentina-like upward explosion of inflation, but only that there was a risk that, unless the expansionary fiscal and monetary policies of 2009 were reversed, the U.S. was about to experience an Argentina-like upward explosion of inflation. And Noah Smith said that was a fair point. I in turn counter-protested to Noah: There was no reason to think that the expansion of the Fed balance sheet from $700B to $1.7T in mid-2009 would create too-much money chasing too-few goods--for as long as the economy was at the zero nominal interest rate lower bound expanding the Fed's balance sheet simply swapped one very low-yield nominal government liability for another with little effect on anybody's net liquidity or risk exposure. The marginal expansion of the projected national debt from the Recovery Act was absolutely trivial, and since the prospect of future health-care spending deficits had not provoked "Argentina" by 2008 there was no risk the additional marginal borrowing of the Recovery Act would provoke "Argentina" in the context of a depressed economy. Financial markets were not pricing in any chance of an upward explosion of inflation. Cochrane could neither (a) point at elements in the configuration of asset (and other) prices demonstrating that people besides him thought "Argentina" was a substantial risk, or (b) explain the market failure that kept people from hedging against the risk in such a way that we could see their hedges in market prices. Thus Cochrane's point that he was just pointing out a "risk of Argentina" did not seem to me to be a fair point at all. If it really was a significant risk, than people ought--at the appropriate odds--to be willing to bet that that risk would actually come to pass. So I asked Noah if he was so willing... Hence we decided on:
I must say that Noah appears to me to not be an expected utility maximizer, or to have a substantially different assessment of the odds than I do: I would have demanded 200-1 to take the Cochrane side of this bet… Mark your calendars now for August 2015… July 29, 2012 at 15:42 in #economics, #highlighted, #monetaryeconomics | Permalink | Comments (54) If reading this gets you Value Above Replacement, then become a free subscriber to this newsletter. And forward it! And if your VAR from this newsletter is in the three digits or more each year, please become a paid subscriber! I am trying to make you readers—and myself—smarter. Please tell me if I succeed, or how I fail…#hoisted-from-the-archives |
HOISTED FROM THE ARCHIVES: Origins of the Noah Smith-Brad DeLong-Dan Wang 2015 Pizza Dinner at Zachary's
Wednesday, 3 September 2025
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)




No comments:
Post a Comment